Painless and Efficient Maturity Testing

Win Cowgill, County Agricultural Agent, Rutgers Cooperative Extension

Jon Clements, Extension Tree Fruit Specialist, University of Massachusetts

Jeremy Compton, North Jersey Tree Fruit Technician, Rutgers University

Our observation has been that few growers utilize the Starch Index (SI) method of determining harvest maturity. Perhaps SI testing is perceived as time consuming and difficult to properly judge. We contend, however, that SI testing is the best and easiest indicator of apple maturity that a grower can use to plan their harvest and storage regimes.

Why is it important to perform SI testing? First, as mentioned, the SI method is probably the best way to judge fruit maturity without expensive equipment. The Sl technique, wherein the starch to sugar ratio is measured, is correlated with ethylene evolution. In fact, ethylene synthesis occurs as fruit ripens. Therefore, the SI index is an inexpensive way to assess the degree to which fruit has converted starch to sugar, and is indicative of the onset and progress of ethylene production.

Secondly, because SI is a reliable indicator of relative fruit maturity, SI testing can help you determine if harvested fruit should be placed in early CA, late CA, or regular cold storage. Remember that, as a rule, fruit with SI readings of 3-4 are suitable for late CA, apples measuring 4-6 on the SI scale are best for early CA, and any fruit reading 6 or above should be placed in regular cold storage or marketed immediately. Of course, reliability in using the SI method for determining apple maturity is predicated on good sampling techniques, i.e.; looking at fruit that has sufficient size and color. Or, in other words, sample apples that you expect are approaching harvest readiness. (Note: Apples going into late CA (available in April-June, etc.) should not average less than 15 lbs. flesh firmness.)

Dr. George Green, Pennsylvania State University, has more details on harvest maturity in the Pennsylavania Tree Fruit Production Guide. He also offers the following" "Over the years charts have been developed for many varieties but some charts went from 1 to 5 while others went from 1 to 7.There was much confusion so the postharvest physiologists at Cornell University have developed a more universally accepted chart that is useful for all varieties. It is being used by researchers in over 20 states in the national apple cultivar-testing program. Cornell has an excellent publication available to help you use the starch-iodine test and to develop an apple maturity program.  The publication also contains a laminated starch iodine chart to aid in interpreting the tests.  I strongly suggest that anyone seriously interested in harvesting high quality apples with good storage potential download a copy of this publication, 'Predicting Harvest Date Windows for Apples (1992)' Information Bulletin 221." Full-color plates show how to use and interpret the starch-iodine test for determining maturity and the best harvest dates for quality, especially important for apples going into storage. Covers McIntosh, Cortland, Empire, Delicious, Mutsu/Crispin, and Idared; dates for other varieties can be interpreted from the information presented. 20 pages. Cost $5.50 This publication can be ordered from Cornell University by calling 607-255-2080 and using a Master Card or VISA credit card to pay for the pub.

Specific starch charts have also been developed for Gala, Liberty, Cortland, and Mutsu. On the West Coast they have also been developed for Fuji.

Having tested tens of thousands of apples over the years, per numerous experimental protocols, we can now suggest a simple, quick and efficient method for evaluating orchard by orchard or block by block SI apple samples. Here is our quick and simple testing technique:

Although the SI is a reliable gauge of many cultivars, such as McIntosh, Empire, Jonathan, Red and Golden Delicious and Macoun, some cultivars do not respond as well to the SI test. Examples include Gala, Honeycrisp, and Fuji, which do not respond well to the SI rating, and should be gauged using background color, soluble solids content, and flesh firmness.

Background color is a very good maturity indicator on Gala and will provide the grower with an accurate maturity gauge. Red color, flesh firmness and soluble solids are not as reliable an indicator of maturity as is background color on this cultivar. Fruit should be harvested for optimum long-term storage quality when the background color of the fruit is changing from a green to yellow color. After that, the background color changes from yellow to cream. It is at this stage that the fruit is ready for immediate sales or short-term storage. Galas will require multiple pickings for optimum fruit quality. Background color is also one of the best indicators of maturity for Fuji cultivars.

Here are some additional resources on fruit maturity testing and for purchasing/making supplies for doing the SI test, including SI Test solution and charts. Also, contact Win Cowgill or Jon Clements if you have further questions or need more information.

From the Ontario Ministry of Agriculture, Food, and Rural Affairs, two publication on using the SI test, including directions for making the solution and charts for McIntosh, Delicious, Empire, Idared, and Spartan

For purchasing SI Test solution and charts

Short video of SI testing procedure (Wes Autio and Jon Clements, August, 2005, QuickTime required)


Always read and follow pesticide labels. © Copyright 2007, Jon Clements, University of Massachusetts, UMass Extension and UMass Fruit Advisor.